Select the search type
  • Site
  • Web
Go Green banner ads

Published on Wednesday, July 12, 2017

Study Shows that Dogs Have A Sense of Justice


Study Shows that Dogs Have A Sense of Justice

A study published in the Current Biology journal has found that dogs and their wild wolf ancestors react similar to humans and primates when put in unfair situations. Researchers have found that dogs and wolves are able to recognize inequity and dislike it in much the same way that humans do.

Building on Previous Studies

Prior to this new study, researchers assumed that the canine aversion to inequity was an adaption from domestication. According to Top Dogs Tips, “scientists believed dogs were learning this behavior from the humans who kept them, assuming it's us who taught canines this sensitivity”. One of the leading studies for this theory was conducted by researchers from Emory University in 2008. Their study began to raise questions about how dogs are aware of inequity and why they react similarly to humans.

Since then, the “inequity awareness through domestication” theory has been widely accepted. But the new study published in the Current Biology journal has findings to disprove this theory. Researchers have compared domesticated dogs and wild wolves to show that domestication is not the link for animals that are able to identify inequity.

Dogs Distinguishing Inequity

This intriguing study was conducted by comparative psychologists at the Messerli Research Institute of the University of Veterinary Medicine in Vienna. The researchers put the canines to the test by making them press a buzzer to receive treats. They observed the reactions of the canines when pressing the button and receiving no treat or a lower quality reward treat than received by their partner. Both the domesticated dogs and wild wolves refused to keep participating in the buzzer test after a while of receiving treats of lesser quality or no treats at all.

The researchers found that the animals would only continue to participate if they didn’t have a partner next to them which they were competing with for the best treat. Wolves in the treat-quality tests exhibited more sensitive behavior than the domesticated dogs. But overall, the canines in higher ranks became frustrated with the tests more quickly.

The scientists believe this sensitivity and refusal to participate stems from the canine’s hierarchical structure. Alpha dogs and leaders of the wolf pack are not used to lesser treatment and therefore got more frustrated and refused to participate more quickly than others. Since the lower ranked canines are not accustomed to preferential treatment, they tolerated the tests for a longer duration of time.

Behavior Not Linked to Domestication

Wild wolves and domesticated dogs were compared in this way to see whether domestication plays a role in the behavior to distinguish inequity. Since the wolves and the dogs reacted similarly to the no-reward and treat-quality tests, it would suggest that domestication is not linked to this sensitivity. The researchers believe that this behavior to inequity is linked to a shared ancestor among humans and canines.

Although the researchers found no link with domestication with regards to the canine behavior towards inequity, they did find that domesticated dogs were less likely to hold a grudge against humans than wild wolves. The scientists conducted another test to see if/how the wild wolves and domesticated dogs would hold a grudge against humans for their unjust behavior. They found that the wolves were more aloof towards humans after the treat experiments were completed. On the other hand, domesticated dogs were just as loving to humans before and after the treat experiments.

This study can also be helpful for people who may be giving preferential treatment in their multi-pet household. It’s important for pet owners to be aware of this behavior towards inequity and attempt to switch to a more fair and equitable way of dealing with dogs.  


Rate this article:
No rating
Comments ()Number of views (143)

Author: AThompson

Categories: Blogs, Research, Animals & Wildlife, Pets



Search Jobs


«July 2017»

Warming Temps Making Antarctica Ripe for Pests' Picking

Rising temperatures over the past 30 years have made the frozen continent a perfect spot for foreign pests, spelling out disaster for its fragile ecosystem.

Read more

Meet Eclipse, Seattle’s Famous Bus-Riding Dog

You wouldn't believe it if you couldn't see it with your very own eyes but it's true! This dog rides the bus to the dog park all by herself!

Read more

EPA Sued by Environmental Organizations for Lack of Pesticide Exposure Protection

The EPA is being further scrutinized for their role in reducing protections for pesticide applicators. Another event in a string of poor choices for the organization.

Read more

Owl Spotted ‘Swimming’ Through a Canyon

It's not everyday you get to see a horned owl doing the breast stroke but this viral footage shows that even the unlikeliest of animals can still surprise us.

Read more

5 Ways to Use Home Technology to Help You Go Green

Home technology is improving with each passing day. We've highlighted just a few recent advancements that'll help you make this world just a bit greener.

Read more

Federal Government Set to Remove the Yellowstone Grizzly Bear

Grizzly bears are finally being removed from the endangered species list. But there still remains a bit of controversy around this important decision.

Read more

Three Baby Raccoons Befriend Some Fishermen

In this video, a bearded fisherman befriends three baby raccoons. Whether it was the beard that brought them in or not, this cute video will warm your heart.

Read more

Killer Whales vs. Fishermen: Who’s Winning?

Killer whales have always been some of the smartest animals in the sea. But now they're actually using their brains to rob fishermen of their catch. 

Read more

Two Adult Elephants Team Up and Save a Baby Elephant

Elephants care for their young more than most other animals. And this video proves that the entire elephant community cares for it's calves.

Read more

Last Chance to Save Coral Reefs

The future of our coral reefs is dimming with each passing day. And scientists have just joined together to issue a final warning.

Read more

Offshore Drilling Blasts Kill Ocean Animals

We all know oil spills can destroy entire ecosystems. But a new study shows that drilling alone is killing off crucial underwater life at an alarming pace.

Read more

Wandering Dog Joins the Vienna Chamber Orchestra During a Live Performance

Watch this hilarious footage of a calm and curious dog crashing an outdoor orchestra performance much to the delight of the audience. 

Read more

Study Shows that Dogs Have A Sense of Justice

We've always thought that a dog's values reflects its owner's. But a recent study shows that canine justice might have a genetic factor tracing all the way back to wolves. 

Read more

Baby Hippo Tries to Recruit a Crocodile as a Playmate

Can you imagine choosing a crocodile as a playmate? It looks like this playful hippo has. Watch as he entertains himself with this unusual friend.

Read more

A Half-Degree Is More Than You Think

A common argument among climate change skeptics is that a few degrees difference won't change the world that much. Boy are they wrong.

Read more

6 Ways to Reduce Your Plastic Consumption

Our inability to dispose of plastics properly is causing a worldwide pollution epidemic. Here are six earth-friendly tips for helping you cut down plastic use.

Read more

Butterfly Metamorphosis Seen Clearly Through a Window

Ever wonder what it's like to see a caterpillar turn into a butterfly? This amazing footage shows you just that by giving you a literal window into a cocoon. 

Read more

Why Clean Coal Is Not The Answer

Clean coal has been championed by many to be the future of energy production. But as the recent failure of a new shows, clean coal is not all it's cracked up to be. 

Read more

‘Step Dog’ Babysits a Litter of Kittens

Check out this viral footage of a responsible pet puppy trying to keep a litter of kittens in line. A monumental task that this dog just can't seem to handle. 

Read more

6 Environmental Benefits of Home Solar Panels

Investing in solar panels is one of the best ways to help reduce your family's impact on the environment. Here's six reasons why. 

Read more

A Segment from Antarctica’s Larsen C Ice Shelf Breaks Free

The Larsen C ice shelf recently broke away and is now adrift in the sea. But as time goes on, the shelf itself is beginning to break apart as well.

Read more

Year-Long Video Captures Intimate Footage of Wild Animals

Watch as an entire year of a tree's life is captured in this footage of a single beech tree in Italy. Animals like bears, deer, badgers and wolves all pop by for a look.

Read more

A Third of the World Is Now Subject to Deadly Heatwaves

Deadly heatwaves are popping up more and more all over the world. And thanks to the far-reaching effects of climate change, we're bound to deal with even more.

Read more

Flyover Video Gives An Up Close and Personal View of Pluto

Check out this amazing footage of Pluto's surface captured by the New Horizon satellite. This is one view that's truly out of this world. 

Read more



    Help Us Go Green
    Help Us Go Green